05 May 2010

¡olé!

cinco de mayo is celebrated more in the usa than in mexico. it's an obvious excuse to let loose with the margaritas & tortilla cheeps, and what sane person would pass that up? i would venture to say that cinco de mayo is being celebrated right now in arizona with at least as much intensity as it is in every other state in our union.

okay, i really don't want to get into the arizona thing except to say that if part of the title of the group to which you belong is "illegal", then maybe that's a clue to your comparitive status. i am not saying that folks everywhere don't deserve a chance at that brass ring we call the american dream. i am not saying that folks who migrate to the usa do not work hard or contribute to their communities in ways both monetary and cultural. i am not saying that we citizens have any more basic human rights simply because we are citizens of the usa than do the folks who are here illegally. all i am saying is that "illegal" does not imply that you are unproductive or undeserving. "illegal" means that you are breaking the law. your choices where the law is concerned are straightforward - obey it or pay the consequences. (and, the slightly less straightforward - change the law.) if you break the law you pay the consequences, even if you don't agree with the law. in fact - even if a lot of people don't agree with the law, you still pay the consequences if you break it (and get caught). so, if you're an illegal immigrant to the usa, you face the possibility each day that you will be brought up against the consequences. now -- if the consequences of breaking the law to be in the usa are less than the consequences of living legally in mexico (or, finland, china, bora bora... anywhere), that is to say that if you are safer, healthier, more productive, able to offer your children more hope, stability, and freedom living in the usa with the status of "illegal" than living legally someplace else - well, then you are probably going to go for it, right? and, who's to blame you for that? seems an easy choice. the thing about it, though, is that making that choice doesn't let you out of suffering the consequences of breaking the laws of the usa - and one of those consequences is that you will bear the label "illegal".



okay, well, good thing i didn't want to get into THAT because gd only knows where we'd end up.

cinco de mayo is not a big holiday in mexico. it's a celebration in one part of mexico - a commemoration of the defeat of the french at puebla on 5 mayo 1862. a typical jaywalking contestant on the tonight show would likely tell you it's mexican independence day, and they'd be wrong. mexican independence day is on 16 september. no worries, though - the proprietor of your local taquería will gladly set you up with tequila and cheeps on cinco de mayo, or any other day. that is, as long as you can prove you are legally old enough to drink.

5 Comments:

At 06 May, 2010 21:16, Blogger Jeff Edmonds said...

"Give me your tired and your poor, your huddled masses yearning to be free, the restless refuse of your teeming shore. Give these, the hopeless tempest tossed to me. I life my lamp beside the golden shore."

 
At 06 May, 2010 21:19, Blogger ace said...

yes. good. but then what? ::sigh:: there is a piece missing between "come on down, you're the next contestant!" and... and...

oh, my ride's here. shit. more later. sorry!

 
At 06 May, 2010 22:04, Blogger ace said...

okay, let's try this again. there's got to be something between just opening the floodgates and letting everyone in, and putting up a big wall and keeping everyone out. right?

 
At 07 May, 2010 09:23, Blogger Jeff Edmonds said...

Yep. That's the hard part that nobody wants to talk about. You're a racist and xenophobe if you mention the problems that unchecked immigration brings. And you're a naive hippie if you talk about the positive effects of immigration.

What's in-between? I'd say offering a path to citizenship for immigrants who come here and go to school and work hard and do not break laws. I'd say doing our best to help address the brutal conditions that these people are trying to escape from. And also doing our best to try to help the people who are frustrated by the effects of the flow of immigration on their daily lives.

Yes, the immigrants who cross the border without papers are here "illegally." But on the other hand this is not the sum of their identity. They are, in some ways, the true bearers of the future of the American dream--the flight from oppressive circumstances, the hope for something better. They are willing to risk anything for this dream. They are even willing to break the law on its behalf.

We--you and I--are here legally. But all we did for that was just be born here. We didn't choose America. They did. Now, it can be said that they should have chosen the legal route, but the legal route takes financial means. If you have no money, the choice to be an American is denied to you, legally.

And on and on and on. I'm sure you know all this. And it doesn't really help to find the middle ground.

 
At 07 May, 2010 18:19, Blogger ace said...

very eloquent, jeff. no kidding. thanks for posting that.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home